Wine Bar
Unclaimed profileGibraltar Restaurant
Lancaster, PA · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Gibraltar Restaurant runs a deep beverage program that spans a 20+ cocktail list, an extensive wine bottle selection, a broad spirits inventory, local draft beer, and two mocktails. The June 2026 libations menu covers signature and classic cocktails, plus an espresso martini flight; the wine list moves from a $22 flight to a $950 Corton Grand Cru. Draft beers lean on Victory, LBC, and St. Boniface.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Wine Flight, which lets you choose any white, red, or sparkling (except splits) in 3 oz pours for $22. The Espresso Martini Flight offers three 3 oz selections from seven variations for $24. For a single pour, the Naked & Famous mixes mezcal, Aperol, pressed lime, and Yellow Chartreuse.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- This suits drinkers who want a serious wine list alongside a full cocktail and spirits program. The $22 wine flight and $24 espresso martini flight allow side-by-side comparison without committing to a full bottle. Local draft beer and two mocktails round out the options for mixed groups.
- When should I go?
- The espresso martini flight and the wine flight are built for comparison, making them a natural fit for an early evening or after-dinner round. The two mocktails provide a non-alcoholic option at the same table.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Signature cocktails are $16-$17 and classics $15-$16. The espresso martini flight is $24. Wine flights are $22; by-the-glass pours run $13-$28. Bottles range from $30 to $950. Draft beers are $7-$8 and bottled beers $6. Mocktails are $9 and non-alcoholic beer $5.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The wine program pairs an award-winning list with a $22 flight option and a bottle range that reaches $950 for a 2018 Corton Grand Cru. The spirits list carries aged expressions like The Macallan 18 YR and Redbreast 21 YR, while the cocktail menu includes an espresso martini flight and a Margarita with four fruit choices.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A June 2026 libations menu lists 20+ signature cocktails, classic cocktails, and an espresso martini flight. Signature options include Strawberry Summer Mule, Naked & Famous, Pina Paloma, Coming Up Roses, and Smoked Vanilla Old Fashioned. Classics range from Manhattan and Negroni to Paper Plane and Vesper Martini. A Margarita offers four fruit choices.
Menu strengths
- — 20+ cocktails split across signature and classic categories, plus an espresso martini flight
- — Espresso Martini Flight lets you choose 3 (3 oz each) from seven variations for $24
- — Margarita option offers Grapefruit, Pineapple, Blood Orange, or Mango
Standout selections
- — Naked & Famous: Mezcal, Aperol, Pressed Lime, Yellow Chartreuse, $17
- — Strawberry Summer Mule: Tito's Vodka, Ginger Beer, Muddled Strawberries, Pressed Lime, Basil Syrup, Basil Leaf, $16
- — Espresso Martini Flight: choose 3 (3 oz each) from seven espresso and dessert martini variations, $24
Pricing: Signature cocktails $16-$17; classic cocktails $15-$16; espresso martini flight $24
Wine
A September 2026 by-the-glass list covers sparkling, white, rosé, and red with 6 oz pours and 3 oz flight pours. The August 2026 bottle list is extensive, spanning Champagne, Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, Riesling, Pinot Noir, Cabernet, Italian varietals, and dessert wines.
Menu strengths
- — Extensive bottle list with deep Champagne, Burgundy, Napa Cabernet, and Italian selections
- — Wine Flight allows any White, Red, or Sparkling (except splits) for $22 in 3 oz pours
- — By-the-glass program includes sparkling, white, rosé, and red options
Standout selections
- — Corton Grand Cru Romanée Conti, Côte de Beaune, Burgundy, 2018, $950
- — Champagne Brut, Laurent-Perrier 1/2 Bottle, Tours-Sur-Marne, NV, $60
- — Cabernet Sauvignon, Silver Oak Alexander Valley, 2019, $170
Pricing: By-the-glass $13-$28; flights $22; bottles $30-$950
Beer
A June 2026 libations menu lists 8 draft beers and 6 bottled beers. Draft selection emphasizes local and regional craft breweries including Victory, LBC, and St. Boniface. Bottled options cover Heineken, Peroni, Stella Artois, Amstel Light, Yuengling Lager, and Corona.
Menu strengths
- — 8 draft beers with an emphasis on local and regional craft breweries
- — Draft list includes Victory Hop Devil Nitro IPA, Victory Dirt Wolf Double IPA, and LBC Lager
- — Bottled beers cover Heineken, Peroni, Stella Artois, Amstel Light, Yuengling Lager, and Corona
Standout selections
- — Victory Hop Devil Nitro IPA, 5.7% ABV, draft, $8
- — Victory Dirt Wolf Double IPA, 8.7% ABV, draft, $8
Pricing: Draft $7-$8; bottled $6
Nonalcoholic
A June 2026 libations menu lists two mocktails: Highnoon and Light of Day. Both can be ordered with alcohol added, Highnoon with Don Julio Blanco ($16) and Light of Day with Botanist ($15). Non-alcoholic beer options include Heineken 00 or O'Doul's.
Menu strengths
- — Two mocktails, Highnoon and Light of Day, each available with an optional spirit addition
- — Non-alcoholic beer options include Heineken 00 or O'Doul's
Standout selections
- — Light of Day: Grapefruit Soda, Pressed Lemon, Rosemary Syrup, Club Soda, Rosemary Sprig & Grapefruit Garnish, $9
Pricing: Mocktails $9; non-alcoholic beer $5
Spirits
A January 2025 spirits list details extensive Scotch, Irish, Japanese, Bourbon, Rye, Tequila, Mezcal, Rum, Gin, Vodka, and other spirits. A 2021 list shows a similarly broad selection including vermouth, amaro, liqueurs, brandy, Cognac, Port, Grappa, Sherry, and Madeira. Prices range from $9 to $315.
Menu strengths
- — Deep spirits inventory across whiskey, agave, rum, gin, and other categories
- — Includes numerous aged and rare expressions such as The Macallan 18 YR, Redbreast 21 YR, and WhistlePig 12 YR
- — Spirits list spans vermouth, amaro, liqueurs, brandy, Cognac, Port, Grappa, Sherry, and Madeira
Standout selections
- — The Macallan Single Malt 18 YR Double Cask, Scotch, Highland, $63
- — Redbreast 21 YR, Irish Whiskey, $42; Comisario 8YR Gran Riserva Añejo, Tequila Añejo & Extra Añejo, $315
Pricing: $9-$315
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.