Restaurant
Unclaimed profileKelly's Half Shell Pub
Crystal River, FL · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Kelly's Half Shell Pub runs a beverage program built for a broad table. Sixteen draught beers include Guinness, Harp, Smithwicks, and local Florida names like Marker 48 and Swamp Head. The happy hour cocktail list stays classic with a Cosmopolitan, Margarita, and Blackberry Sangria, all $5-$7. Spirits get a similar treatment, with $3 house liquors and $4 pours of Titos, Bombay, Buffalo Trace, and Paddy's. Wine is the thinnest part, though glasses get $2 off at happy hour.
- What should I order?
- Start with a Guinness or a Marker 48 'Mermaid's Milk' from the draught list, then consider a happy hour cocktail like the Irish Maid or Pineapple Sidecar. For a spirit pour, Buffalo Trace or Paddy's Irish Whiskey at $4 during happy hour is a straightforward choice.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Anyone ordering across a group with mixed preferences: draught beer drinkers, cocktail fans who want recognizable classics, and spirit drinkers looking for value pours. The program is not aimed at wine-first diners.
- When should I go?
- Happy hour is the clear time to visit for the $5-$7 cocktails, $3 house liquors, $4 named spirits, and draught discounts.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Happy hour cocktails run $5-$7. House liquors are $3 and named spirits are $4 during happy hour. Draught discounts are $1 off 20 oz domestic and $2 off 20 oz craft.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The draught list is the anchor: sixteen beers with styles and ABV, mixing Irish standards like Guinness, Harp, and Smithwicks with Florida names like Marker 48, Swamp Head, and Oyster City.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
Five happy hour cocktails with ingredient lists: Cosmopolitan, Margarita, Blackberry Sangria, Irish Maid, and Pineapple Sidecar. Priced $5-$7. A customer account notes creativity and singles out one cocktail as a standout. The list is approachable and classic rather than deep.
Menu strengths
- — Five named cocktails with full ingredient lists on the happy hour menu
- — Happy hour pricing at $5-$7 across the cocktail list
- — A customer account describes the craft cocktail list as creative
Standout selections
- — Irish Maid — Irish whiskey, elderflower, cucumber, and lemon, $7
- — Pineapple Sidecar — brandy, orange liqueur, pineapple, and lemon, $5
Pricing: Happy hour cocktails $5-$7
Wine
Wine gets a happy hour discount of $2 off by the glass. White wine is used in the garlic-butter mussels and garlic-butter oysters, and red wine vinegar appears in the chili mignonette. The program is small and functionally tied to the kitchen.
Menu strengths
- — Happy hour offers $2 off wines by the glass
- — White wine is used in garlic-butter mussels and garlic-butter oysters
Standout selections
- — Happy hour offers $2 off wines by the glass.
Pricing: $2 off wines by the glass during happy hour
Beer
Sixteen draught beers with styles and ABV listed, spanning Irish stouts and lagers, Florida craft, and national names. Happy hour discounts both domestic and craft 20 oz pours. Beer also shows up in the fish & chips, crispy shrimp, Guinness mussels, and Rueben eggrolls.
Menu strengths
- — 16 draught beers with styles and ABV listed
- — Happy hour discounts of $1 off 20 oz domestic and $2 off 20 oz craft draughts
- — Beer is used in four dishes including Guinness mussels and fish & chips
Standout selections
- — Guinness — Dark Irish Dry Stout 4.2%; Marker 48 'Mermaid's Milk' — Milk Stout 5.8%
- — Dogfish Grateful Dead — Juicy Pale Ale 5.3%
Pricing: Happy hour: $1 off 20 oz domestic draughts, $2 off 20 oz craft draughts
Spirits
Happy hour offers $3 house liquors and $4 pours from a named list: Titos Vodka, Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, Bacardi Superior Rum, Bombay Dry Gin, Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Four Roses Whiskey, and Paddy's Irish Whiskey. Spirits also appear in cocktails and food dishes.
Menu strengths
- — Seven named spirits at $4 during happy hour
- — $3 house liquors during happy hour; Spirits are used in cocktails and food dishes
Standout selections
- — Buffalo Trace Bourbon — $4 happy hour pour
- — Paddy's Irish Whiskey — $4 happy hour pour
Pricing: Happy hour: $3 house liquors, $4 named spirits
How it sits with the food
Beer is used in the fish & chips, crispy shrimp, Guinness mussels, and Rueben eggrolls. White wine appears in the garlic-butter mussels and garlic-butter oysters, and red wine vinegar is in the chili mignonette for oysters.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.