Restaurant
Unclaimed profileMatt and Tony's Kitchen x Tavern
Columbus, OH · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Matt and Tony's Kitchen x Tavern runs a beverage program that leans heavily on local Ohio producers. The draft list is a who's who of the state's breweries, and the cocktail menu is broad and affordable, with a few twists on classics. Wine is a functional afterthought. A solid tavern pour, not a destination for oenophiles.
- What should I order?
- Start with the CBC Bodhi double IPA or the Barley's Bloodthirst Wheat to sample Ohio brewing. For cocktails, the Matt's Old Fashioned is a straightforward Evan Williams bourbon build, while the Espresso Martini gets a cold brew kick. Brunch calls for a Mimosa carafe.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Local beer enthusiasts will find plenty to explore among the dozen Ohio drafts. Cocktail drinkers looking for recognizable, reasonably priced drinks will be satisfied. Wine purists may find the list too basic, but casual drinkers will find a safe pour.
- When should I go?
- Stop by for a post-work beer or a weekend brunch. The brunch drink menu suggests a lively late-morning crowd, while the draft list suits an afternoon or evening stop.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails run $12–$13, and a brunch Mimosa is $6.75, with a carafe at $18. Beer and wine prices are not listed, but the cocktail pricing suggests a mid-range tavern cost.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The beer program is the clear standout, with a draft list that spotlights nine Ohio breweries and a range of styles from a 4.2% lager to an 8.3% double IPA. The cocktail menu also nods to local spirits, including Watershed vodka and gin.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A broad house list covers classics and seasonal refreshers, with several featuring local Watershed spirits. Prices are modest. No community feedback confirms quality, but the range and pricing suggest a competent, crowd-pleasing approach.
Menu strengths
- — Eleven house cocktails including seasonal summer options and brunch drinks.
- — Incorporates local spirits like Watershed vodka and gin.
Standout selections
- — Matt's Old Fashioned – Evan Williams Small Batch Bourbon, simple syrup, orange bitters, Luxardo cherry.
- — Espresso Martini – Luxardo espresso liqueur, vanilla vodka, cold brew, with optional flavor additions.
- — Gingerberry Mule – Watershed vodka, black raspberry liqueur, lime, ginger beer.
- — Spiced Pear Gimlet – Watershed Four Peel gin, St. George spiced pear liqueur, lime.
Pricing: Matt's Old Fashioned $12, Espresso Martini $13, Mimosa $6.75, Mimosa Carafe $18
Wine
The wine list is a generic selection of eight types, covering red, white, sparkling, and rosé. No specific producers or vintages are listed, and there is no community feedback. It's a serviceable backup to the beer and cocktail programs.
Menu strengths
- — Offers a basic range of wine styles to cover most preferences.
Pricing: No pricing evidence available
Beer
The draft beer program is a standout, with 12 taps from nine Ohio breweries. Styles span from light lagers to imperial blonds and double IPAs, plus cider and a non-alcoholic option. Community feedback specifically praises the local selection.
Menu strengths
- — Twelve drafts from nine Ohio breweries, including Market Garden, Mad Tree, and CBC.
- — Wide style range from 4.2% lager to 8.3% double IPA, plus cider and non-alcoholic beer.
Standout selections
- — CBC Bodhi – Double IPA with Citra hops, 8.3% ABV.
- — Barley's Bloodthirst Wheat – Blood orange, citrusy, floral wheat, 5.4% ABV.
- — Market Garden Lemon Shandy – Pale wheat with sweet-citrus notes, 4.5% ABV.
- — Land Grant Pool Party – Clean, floral, crisp pilsner, 5.4% ABV.
Pricing: No pricing evidence available
Nonalcoholic
The non-alcoholic program is minimal, with a single non-alcoholic beer option from Brewdog. No mocktails or other NA beverages are listed, but the option exists for designated drivers or those abstaining.
Standout selections
- — Brewdog Cold AF Non-Alcoholic – A non-alcoholic beer option.
Pricing: No pricing evidence available
Spirits
The spirits program is defined by the cocktail list, which uses a range of accessible brands from Evan Williams to Watershed. No dedicated spirits list or tasting menu exists, but the integration into cocktails shows a thoughtful approach.
Menu strengths
- — Spirits are used across a varied cocktail menu, from bourbon to tequila.
Pricing: No dedicated spirits pricing available
How it sits with the food
The brunch drinks like the Mimosa and French 75 pair naturally with breakfast fare, while the hoppy CBC IPA and citrusy Barley's Bloodthirst Wheat would complement pub-style food. The M&T Margarita's lime and agave could cut through rich dishes.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.