Restaurant
Unclaimed profileMatty's Bar & Grille
New Berlin, WI · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Matty's Bar & Grille pours a serious bourbon program—over 100 selections, private barrels, and a Spirit Society—alongside a playful cocktail list with on-tap old fashioneds and margaritas. The beer and wine lists are workmanlike but broad. This is a bar that rewards bourbon enthusiasts and casual drinkers alike, with to-go cocktails and beer buckets adding practical appeal.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Matty's Old Fashioned on Tap, a house signature with Elijah Craig and amaretto. Bourbon fans should order a pour of W.L. Weller 12 Year or a private barrel selection. The Espresso Martini is a solid modern choice.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Bourbon collectors and whiskey society members will find deep value here. Casual drinkers can rely on the approachable cocktail list and familiar beer buckets. The THC lemonade and non-alcoholic beers give options for those abstaining.
- When should I go?
- Evenings are likely busy; the Spirit Society events and seasonal Big Backyard Grille (summer) add appeal. A weekday visit may offer a quieter chance to explore the bourbon list.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Signature cocktails run $8–$13; house wine is $7 a glass; bourbon pours start around $6.50 and climb to $150 for rare selections. Beer buckets offer group value at $20–$28.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The bourbon program is the centerpiece: over 100 labels, private barrels, and a membership club that rewards regulars. The on-tap old fashioned is a clever, low-friction way to serve a classic, and the to-go cocktail bottles extend the bar's reach.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A creative signature list with on-tap options and house-made syrups. Pricing is fair for the quality. Limited full-menu detail and community feedback keep this from scoring higher.
Menu strengths
- — On-tap old fashioned and margarita offer speed and consistency.
- — House-made syrups and fresh juices show care in preparation.
Standout selections
- — Matty's Old Fashioned on Tap: Elijah Craig, amaretto, house syrups, choice of sweet/sour/seltzer/press/ginger ale.
- — Espresso Martini: Ketel One, Mr. Black, cold brew, simple syrup.
- — Blackberry Smash: Jack Daniel's Blackberry, fresh lime, house blackberry syrup.
Pricing: Signature drinks $8–$13; Espresso Martini $13; flavor add-ons +$1.
Wine
A serviceable wine list with multiple categories and price points, but lacking depth in vintages and regions. House wine is a good value.
Menu strengths
- — Diverse selection across rosé, sparkling, white, red, and house wine.
- — Multiple price points from budget to premium.; Available by glass and bottle.
Standout selections
- — Groth Sauvignon Blanc – a premium pour at $18 glass.
- — Kendall-Jackson Chardonnay – reliable, accessible white.
- — Bieler Pere & Fils Rosé – bottle only, $34.
Pricing: House wine $7 glass/$24 bottle; Kendall-Jackson Chardonnay $10/$38; Groth Sauvignon Blanc $18/$54.
Beer
A broad, crowd-pleasing beer list with local Wisconsin drafts and value buckets. Lacks individual pricing and detailed rotation info.
Menu strengths
- — Wide variety from domestic macros to local craft.
- — Includes non-alcoholic options.; Beer buckets offer group value.
Standout selections
- — Spotted Cow (New Glarus) – Wisconsin classic.
- — Riverwest Stein (Lakefront) – local lager.
- — Hopspitality (Eagle Park) – rotating craft IPA.
Pricing: Domestic buckets 5 for $20 inside, 5 for $24 outside; White Claw bucket $25; Carbliss bucket $28.
Nonalcoholic
Limited but functional: a few non-alcoholic beers and a THC drink. No dedicated mocktail menu, which caps the score.
Menu strengths
- — THC drink provides an alternative for those seeking a buzz without alcohol.
Standout selections
- — Matty's Mellowade Raspberry Lemonade – 5mg THC can.
Pricing: Matty's Mellowade 4-pack $24.99 + tax.
Spirits
An exceptional bourbon program with over 100 selections, rare allocations, and private barrels. The Spirit Society adds a unique membership angle. This is the clear highlight.
Menu strengths
- — Over 100 bourbons including Pappy Van Winkle, George T. Stagg, and W.L. Weller.
- — Spirit Society offers discounted pours, barrel pick access, and priority events.
Standout selections
- — Pappy Van Winkle 15 Year – $75/1oz, $150/2oz.
- — George T. Stagg – $40/1oz, $80/2oz.
- — W.L. Weller 12 Year – $16/1oz, $32/2oz.
- — E.H. Taylor, Jr. Barrel Proof – $25/1oz, $50/2oz.
Pricing: Bourbon pours $6.50–$150 for 1oz/2oz; Spirit Society membership $50 + tax.
How it sits with the food
Pair the Blackberry Smash with grilled meats; the White Peach Sangria suits lighter fare. The extensive bourbon list invites classic pairings with bar food like burgers or wings, though no specific food pairings are detailed.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.