Restaurant
Unclaimed profileMuddy Waters Oyster Bar
Pittsburgh, PA · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Muddy Waters Oyster Bar runs a beverage program that pairs a raw bar with a cocktail list that has some real personality—think raisin-infused bourbon and Fresno-chili tequila. A deep wine list reaches from $44 bottles to Krug Rosé, while happy hour brings boilermakers and discounted bubbles. House-infused Bloody Marys and a trio of Coronitas keep things playful.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Sazerac or the Bayou Bonfire, which layers raisin-infused bourbon and hickory smoke. The Louisiana Pearl, an oyster-shell dirty martini, is a must for the curious. For a lighter sip, the West Coast Shooter hits with mezcal and cucumber. During happy hour, a boilermaker with Old Forester and a can of PBR is a solid value.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Oyster bar regulars who like their cocktails with a twist, bourbon drinkers exploring hickory-smoked infusions, and anyone who enjoys a well-stocked champagne list without the stuffy atmosphere. Brunch crowds will appreciate the house-infused Bloody Mary bar.
- When should I go?
- Brunch is another good occasion for the specialty Bloody Marys and punch.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails run $11–$14, shooters around $9, and wine by the glass $11–$20. Bottles start at $44 and climb to $350 for Krug Rosé. Beers are $4.50–$7, and a Pickle Back shot is $5.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The cocktail list leans into theatrical ingredients—hickory smoke, oyster shell, Fresno chili, raisin-infused bourbon—and the house-infused Bloody Marys offer five different vodkas and a tequila. The champagne list, with Dom Perignon and Krug Rosé, is a surprising pairing for a casual oyster bar.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A creative, well-priced list that balances classics like the Sazerac with original builds like the Bayou Bonfire and Devil's Snare. The Louisiana Pearl adds a clever oyster-shell twist. Happy hour and brunch expand the range with boilermakers and infused Bloody Marys.
Menu strengths
- — Diverse menu with inventive ingredients such as raisin-infused bourbon and Fresno chili.
- — Happy hour and brunch offerings broaden the cocktail appeal.
Standout selections
- — Bayou Bonfire: raisin-infused bourbon, hazelnut, brown sugar, and hickory smoke.
- — Devil's Snare: Fresno chili tequila, snow chrysanthemum, lime, smoke cinnamon bitters.
- — Louisiana Pearl: vodka and gin with oyster shell, dry vermouth, olive, pickle brine.
- — West Coast Shooter: mezcal, cucumber, basil, lime, jalapeño.
Pricing: Cocktails $11–$14; shooters $9.
Wine
A broad list covering red, white, rosé, and sparkling, with a serious premium champagne section. The happy hour discounts on bubbles make it accessible. International selections include Italy, New Zealand, and California.
Menu strengths
- — Premium champagne options including Dom Perignon and Krug Rosé.
- — Happy hour specials: $10 off bubbles and $20 off champagne.
- — Wide price range accommodates casual and celebratory pours.
Standout selections
- — Krug Rosé, $350/bottle.; Dom Perignon 2012, $300/bottle.
- — Moet & Chandon Imperial, $20/glass, $85/bottle.
- — Pinot Grigio, Benvolio, Italy, $13/glass, $52/bottle.
Pricing: Glasses $11–$20; bottles $44–$350.
Beer
A solid selection of craft and domestic beers on draft and in cans, including Cigar City Brown Ale and Guinness. The happy hour boilermakers and Trio of Coronitas add fun value. Non-alcoholic option available.
Menu strengths
- — Good variety from craft to domestic.; Boilermaker specials with Old Forester Bourbon.
- — Trio of Coronitas served on ice with limes.
Standout selections
- — Cigar City Brown Ale, $6.; Atomic Dog Semi-Dry Cider, $7.
- — PBR 16 oz, $4.50.; Guinness, 16 oz nitro.
Pricing: Beers $4.50–$7.
Nonalcoholic
The menu includes three non-alcoholic spritzes and a non-alcoholic hazy beer. While pricing is absent, the options are thoughtful and varied, catering to sober-curious guests.
Menu strengths
- — Multiple non-alcoholic cocktail options.; Includes a non-alcoholic beer.
Standout selections
- — Cucumber Basil Spritz.; Hibiscus Rose Spritz.
Pricing: No pricing listed for non-alcoholic drinks.
Spirits
The back bar underpins a creative cocktail program with a wide range of spirits. House infusions for Bloody Marys and bourbon-forward boilermakers show a hands-on approach. No dedicated spirits list, but the usage is evident.
Menu strengths
- — Wide range of spirits used across cocktails.; House-infused vodkas and tequila for Bloody Marys.
Standout selections
- — Bayou Bonfire: raisin-infused bourbon, hazelnut, hickory smoke.
- — Bloody Mary with smoked jalapeno tequila.
- — Pickle Back: Jameson + house pickle juice.
Pricing: Spirit-based cocktails range $9–$14; Pickle Back shot $5.
How it sits with the food
The raw bar's oysters and seafood towers call for the French 75 or a crisp glass of Pinot Grigio. The Bayou Bonfire's smoky bourbon could stand up to richer seafood dishes, while the Louisiana Pearl's brine echoes the oyster shell itself.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.