Restaurant
Unclaimed profilePublick House 23
Pleasant Valley, NY · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Publick House 23 runs a wide-ranging beverage program: a seasonal cocktail list with muddled-fruit and herb-driven drinks, a six-flavor margarita/mezcalita line, 18 taps, a sizable spirits shelf, and a dedicated zero-proof section. The cocktail list is the most ambitious part, while beer and wine play supporting roles.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Basil Bourbon Bliss, a Bulleit bourbon, lime, Demerara, and muddled basil combination that shows the program's herb-forward style. If you prefer something tart, the Summer Solstice pairs Hendrick's gin with lemon, agave, and muddled blackberries.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Cocktail drinkers who like seasonal fruit-and-herb combinations will find plenty to explore. The dedicated zero-proof section also makes this a workable stop for people skipping alcohol.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The beverage program stands out for its breadth: a spring cocktail list with eight named drinks, a margarita/mezcalita line in six flavors, ten signature cocktails, 18 taps, and a zero-proof section that includes both non-alcoholic cocktails and N/A beers.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A deep cocktail program split into spring, signature, and margarita/mezcalita lists. Spring drinks lean on muddled fruit and herbs, while the margarita/mezcalita lineup offers six fruit flavors.
Menu strengths
- — Seasonal spring cocktails include eight named drinks with specific spirits, citrus, and fresh ingredients.
- — A six-flavor margarita/mezcalita line expands the program beyond standard cocktails.
- — Ten signature cocktails give repeat visitors a stable core list.
Standout selections
- — Basil Bourbon Bliss: Bulleit bourbon, lime, Demerara, muddled basil.
- — Summer Solstice: Hendrick's gin, lemon, agave, muddled blackberries.
- — Rustic Mule: Bulleit bourbon, lemon, simple, muddled strawberries, ginger beer.
Wine
The wine list is conventional but competent, covering nine varietals from California, Argentina, Italy, France, and Washington. Each pour is listed with a producer and brief tasting note, which is helpful for by-the-glass ordering.
Menu strengths
- — Nine varietals span still reds, whites, and a sparkling Prosecco.
- — Producers are named for each wine, with tasting notes provided.
Standout selections
- — Cabernet - Grayson Cellars — Blackberry, raspberries, toasted French oak, vanilla (California)
- — Cap Royal Sauvignon Blanc: crisp green apple and floral fruitiness.
Beer
A large draft system with 18 taps plus bottles and cans covers a broad range. The inclusion of two non-alcoholic options, including a locally crafted N/A IPA, shows attention to drinkers who want beer flavor without alcohol.
Menu strengths
- — 18 taps provide a sizable rotating draft selection.
- — Menu includes bottles and cans alongside draft.; Non-alcoholic beer options include Heineken 0.0 and Industrial Arts Safety Glasses.
Standout selections
- — Industrial Arts Safety Glasses: locally crafted N/A IPA with Citra, Mosaic, Cascade.
Nonalcoholic
A dedicated zero-proof section lists two non-alcoholic cocktails and two N/A beers, a rare and useful range. The cocktails are simple but thoughtfully composed, using ingredients like lavender simple and coconut.
Menu strengths
- — Dedicated zero-proof section includes both cocktails and beer.
- — Non-alcoholic cocktails are named and specified with ingredients.
Standout selections
- — If You Like Pina Colada: pineapple, coconut, lime, lemon-lime soda.
Spirits
A broad spirits list covers bourbon, Scotch, tequila, vodka, and more, with a mix of approachable and premium labels. Bourbon and Scotch selections are particularly deep, including Buffalo Trace and Macallan 12.
Menu strengths
- — Bourbon list includes six named brands, from Buffalo Trace to Maker's Mark.
- — Scotch list spans seven bottles, including Laphroaig 10 and Oban 14.
Standout selections
- — Macallan 12: a premium single malt Scotch.; Buffalo Trace: a well-regarded bourbon.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.