Bar
Unclaimed profileShipwrecked Paradise Island
Sacramento, CA · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Shipwrecked Paradise Island runs a serious tiki program in built on house-made orgeat and falernum and a rum list topping 30 expressions. The 1944 Mai Tai blends four premium rums, while the Zombie Jet Pilot packs a 151-proof float. Cocktails are organized by strength, from easy sippers to pirate-level. A compact wine and beer list fills gaps, and mocktails cover non-drinkers. Customers describe the drinks as great and refreshing, not too sweet.
- What should I order?
- Start with the 1944 Mai Tai, a blend of Appleton Estate 12yr, Rhum Clemente VSOP, Plantaray O.F.T.D., and Smith & Cross. For something stronger, the Zombie Jet Pilot—limited to one per guest—pours 151 proof rum down the straw. The Demerara Old Fashioned offers a bourbon-rum hybrid, and the Painkiller brings pineapple ice cream into the mix.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Tiki enthusiasts will appreciate the depth of rum and classic recipes. Those new to tiki can ease in with strength-level categories. The bar's playful pirate theme suits groups celebrating or seeking a themed night out. Mocktail drinkers have a few non-alcoholic options, though the selection is limited.
- When should I go?
- Thursday evenings feature Mojito Night with pitchers at $20, a lively option for groups. The bar accepts reservations for parties up to 24, making it suitable for planned gatherings. No specific time-of-day guidance is supported beyond that.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails range from $9 for Voodoo Island Jungle Juice to $32 for the Pirates Punch Bowl, with most between $15 and $18. Shooters are $10 each. Wine by the glass runs $19–$28, and beer is $7.50–$8.50. Premium rum pours reach $40 for Appleton Estate 21yr.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The program's centerpiece is a 30-plus rum list and cocktails built on house-made orgeat and falernum. Strength-level categorization—from Easy Drinking to Pirate Strength—gives structure to the menu. The Zombie Jet Pilot's 151-proof straw pour is a theatrical touch. Self-described as the number one tiki bar, the venue leans into its island identity.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A broad tiki menu with house-made orgeat and falernum, classics like the 1944 Mai Tai, and originals like the Zombie Jet Pilot. Strength levels from Easy Drinking to Pirate Strength guide choices.
Menu strengths
- — House-made almond orgeat and falernum demonstrate craft commitment.
- — Wide variety of tiki classics and originals, with strength-level categorization.
Standout selections
- — 1944 Mai Tai: Appleton Estate 12yr, Rhum Clemente VSOP, Plantaray O.F.T.D., Smith & Cross, dry curaçao, orgeat, lime, rock candy syrup.
- — Zombie Jet Pilot: Bacardi 8yr, Plantaray O.F.T.D., Xaymaca, falernum, spices, citrus, angostura, absinthe, with a 151 proof rum float.
- — Painkiller: Pusser's Navy Rum, pineapple ice cream, tropical juices, coconut cream, nutmeg.
Pricing: $9-$32
Wine
A compact wine list with recognizable California and New Zealand labels. Sparkling, red, white, and rosé options are available, but the selection is limited compared to the cocktail program. Prices are moderate for a bar setting.
Menu strengths
- — Offers a selection of well-known wine brands.; Includes sparkling, red, white, and rosé categories.
Standout selections
- — Gloria Ferrer Sonoma Brut; Meiomi Pinot Noir
Pricing: $19-$28 per glass
Beer
A five-beer list spans hazy IPA, fresh-squeezed IPA, stout, lager, and salt-lime lager. Seasonal beers appear while supplies last. Simple, affordable, and adequate for a tiki bar.
Menu strengths
- — Variety of styles from IPA to lager.; Reasonable pricing below $9.
Standout selections
- — Cali Craft Cool Kidz Hazy IPA (7.2% ABV)
- — Stone Buenaveza Salt & Lime Lager
Pricing: $7.50-$8.50
Nonalcoholic
Three mocktails—Mango Tango, Agave Spritz, and Virgin Painkiller—offer thoughtful non-alcoholic options. The Virgin Painkiller mirrors the cocktail's pineapple-coconut profile. Prices are in line with the bar's entry-level cocktails.
Menu strengths
- — Includes a Virgin Painkiller that echoes the classic tiki flavor.
- — All mocktails are priced at $11 or less.
Standout selections
- — Virgin Painkiller: pineapple ice cream, tropical juices, coconut cream, nutmeg.
- — Agave Spritz: organic agave nectar, prickly pear, fresh lime juice, seltzer.
Pricing: $9-$11
Spirits
An extensive spirits list, headlined by over 30 rum expressions including aged and premium bottlings. Tequila, brandy, cognac, pisco, gin, vodka, and whiskey round out the selection. Prices vary widely, with many pours unlisted.
Menu strengths
- — Deep rum selection with rare and premium offerings.
- — Includes a range of agave, whiskey, and other spirits.
Standout selections
- — Appleton Estate 21yr; Plantaray XO 20th Anniversary
Pricing: $8.50-$40
How it sits with the food
The food menu features seafood and island-inspired bites, which pair naturally with the tropical, citrus-forward cocktails. The Painkiller's pineapple and coconut cream complements grilled or fried seafood, while the Demerara Old Fashioned's rich, spiced profile suits heavier island fare.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.