Restaurant
Unclaimed profileTally's Tap & Eatery
Waukesha, WI · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Tally's Tap & Eatery fields a surprisingly deep beverage program for a casual spot. The cocktail menu is extensive, with a $10 section of inventive house drinks like Banana Hammock and Hurricane Tally, plus THC-infused options. A serious bourbon list includes Blanton's and Weller Full Proof, while beer spans domestic standards, craft cans, and non-alcoholic choices. House wine is simple but affordable.
- What should I order?
- Start with a $10 house cocktail like the Banana Hammock or Spiked Lemonade. Bourbon fans should explore the 2-ounce pours, especially rare labels like Blanton's or EH Taylor. Beer drinkers can grab a Lakefront craft can or a Yuengling tall boy. For a lighter option, try a $7 mocktail like the Junipre Mule.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Cocktail enthusiasts looking for creative, budget-friendly drinks will appreciate the $10 menu. Bourbon collectors will find rare pours at accessible prices. Groups with varied tastes will like the extensive beer selection, including non-alcoholic options. The THC-infused cocktails offer a novel experience for those interested.
- When should I go?
- Wednesday features $3.25 domestic bottles and $5 off 2-ounce bourbon pours. Monday has $5 premium tap beers, and Thursday has $3 tall boys.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails run $8-$11, mocktails $7, and house wine $8 per glass. Beer specials can drop bottles to $3.25 and tall boys to $3. Bourbon pours are discounted on Wednesday, but individual spirit prices are not listed.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The standout is the bourbon list, which includes allocated bottles like Blanton's, Weller Full Proof, and Eagle Rare. The cocktail program is equally notable for its themed $10 drinks and THC-infused options. Daily specials and a broad beer selection make it a neighborhood go-to.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
Creative, well-priced cocktail menu with themed sections and house-made syrups. Includes THC-infused options for novelty. Standout drinks like Banana Hammock and Hurricane Tally show effort beyond standard bar fare.
Menu strengths
- — Diverse cocktail menu with creative house specialties; THC-infused options provide a unique twist
Standout selections
- — Banana Hammock: Malibu, cream de banana, Rumchata, pineapple juice
- — Hurricane Tally: Captain Morgan, Bacardi, passion fruit, orange juice, fresh lime
- — Spiked Lemonade: Tito's with choice of fresh fruit syrup
Pricing: $8-$11; $10 for the Tally's $10 Drinks section
Wine
Basic house wine selection at a fair price. Seven varietals cover standard preferences, but no depth or reserve options. Wednesday Sutter Home splits add a value angle.
Menu strengths
- — Standard selection of house wines at a reasonable price
Pricing: $8 per glass, Cabernet $7
Beer
Broad beer selection covering domestic, imports, craft cans, seltzers, and non-alcoholic. Local craft representation from Lakefront and Third Space.
Menu strengths
- — Wide variety of beer styles and brands; Includes non-alcoholic beer options
Standout selections
- — Third Space Happy Place (5.3% ABV)
Pricing: Premium tap $5 Monday, domestic bottles $3.25 Wednesday, tall boys $3 Thursday
Nonalcoholic
Four well-crafted mocktails at a fair price, using non-alcoholic spirits and fresh ingredients. Non-alcoholic beer options add variety. A solid choice for designated drivers or those avoiding alcohol.
Menu strengths
- — Variety of non-alcoholic mocktails; Includes non-alcoholic beer options
Standout selections
- — Junipre Mule with non-alcoholic botanical spirit
- — Organic Paloma in a salted clay jar
Pricing: Mocktails $7 each
Spirits
Impressive spirits list, especially bourbon and rye, with rare allocations like Blanton's, Weller Full Proof, and Eagle Rare. Tequila selection includes Patron and Don Julio. Scotch and Irish offerings are standard but adequate.
Menu strengths
- — Large and diverse spirits selection; Includes rare and premium bourbons
Standout selections
- — Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon; Weller Full Proof Bourbon
Pricing: 2oz bourbon pour $5 off on Wednesday
How it sits with the food
No food evidence was available, but the cocktail list's fruity, sweet profiles would pair with bar snacks or burgers. Bourbon's bold flavors suit grilled meats or barbecue. The light, citrusy mocktails could complement salads or seafood.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.