Restaurant
Unclaimed profileThe HC Tavern + Kitchen
Fishers, IN · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
The HC Tavern + Kitchen runs a beverage program that leans on personality: a Signature 'Elmo Cola' spiked with cherry vanilla whiskey, espresso martini flights, and a brunch Bloody Mary cart. The wine list spans Prosecco to Paso Robles Cabernet, while local Indiana drafts and alcohol-removed cocktails broaden the appeal. Cocktail quality earns praise from guests, though the program's breadth outpaces its documented depth.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Signature 'Elmo Cola' or the Rare Saint Manhattan. For a group, the Espresso Martini Flight covers classic, bourbon, and Carajillo styles. A glass of Justin Cabernet Sauvignon pairs well with heartier fare.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Cocktail enthusiasts seeking signature drinks and flights will find plenty. Brunch crowds can explore the Bloody Mary & Mimosa Cart. Non-alcoholic drinkers have creative options like the Madhatter's Spritz.
- When should I go?
- Brunch is a standout occasion, with the Espresso Martini Flight and Bloody Mary & Mimosa Cart. Evenings suit the full cocktail and wine list.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails start at $13; the Espresso Martini Flight is $25, and the Mimosa Bucket runs $46. Wine by the glass ranges from $11 to $20, with bottles up to $70.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The Signature 'Elmo Cola' nods to the Huse Culinary family's St. Elmo Steak House heritage. Brunch features a Bloody Mary & Mimosa Cart and espresso martini flights. Alcohol-removed cocktails and Athletic Brewing beers round out a program that tries to cover every base.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
Creative signature list with a wide spirit base, brunch flights, and a Bloody Mary cart. Prices span $13 to $46.
Menu strengths
- — Signature cocktails like the Rare Saint Manhattan and Pop's Old Fashioned use quality spirits.
- — Brunch features a Bloody Mary & Mimosa Cart and an Espresso Martini Flight.
Standout selections
- — Signature 'Elmo Cola' – Coke with St. Elmo Cherry Vanilla whiskey and drunken cherries.
- — Rare Saint Manhattan – Rare Saint 5 yr bourbon, sweet vermouth, orange bitters.
Pricing: Huckelberry Mule $13; Espresso Martini Flight $25; Mimosa Bucket $46.
Wine
International selection covering sparkling, white, red, and rosé. Available by glass and bottle, with a $5 off glass promotion. Some wines lack listed prices.
Menu strengths
- — Diverse regions from California to France and Australia.
Standout selections
- — Hampton Water Rosé – France, $11 glass/$58 bottle.
- — Justin Cabernet Sauvignon – Paso Robles, $20 glass/$70 bottle.
Pricing: Avissi Prosecco $13 glass/$46 bottle; Gloria Ferrer Brut $14/$50; Justin Cabernet Sauvignon $20/$70.
Beer
Draft list highlights Indiana breweries like Four Day Ray and Metazoa, plus national craft icons. Includes non-alcoholic Athletic Brewing options. No prices listed.
Menu strengths
- — Local Indiana craft beer representation.; Non-alcoholic beer options from Athletic Brewing.
Standout selections
- — Three Floyds Zombie Dust Pale Ale – Munster, IN.
- — Bell's Two Hearted Ale – Comstock, MI.
Pricing: Beer prices not listed; $3 off draft beer promotion.
Nonalcoholic
Thoughtful non-alcoholic cocktails using alcohol-removed spirits like Almave and Mionetto. Includes Athletic Brewing beers and fresh juices. Prices mostly unlisted.
Menu strengths
- — Creative alcohol-removed cocktails such as Coastal Crush and Madhatter's Spritz.
Standout selections
- — Madhatter's Spritz – Mionetto alcohol-removed Prosecco, Earl Grey tea, cardamom, honey, citrus.
- — Coastal Crush – Almave alcohol-removed agave spirit, blood orange, yuzu, pineapple, soda.
Pricing: Fresh orange juice $4; most non-alcoholic drink prices not listed.
Spirits
Spirits program is evident through cocktail descriptions, featuring bourbon, rye, vodka, gin, rum, and tequila. Premium brands like Rare Saint and Barkeep are highlighted, with promotions on select spirits.
Menu strengths
- — Promotions on specific brands like Barkeep vodka and Rare Saint whiskey.
Standout selections
- — Pop's Old Fashioned – Rare Saint rye, Bitter Cube bitters, orange peel.
- — Espresso Martini – Lavazza espresso, Barkeep vodka, vanilla, Nocello, Kahlúa, Bittermens chocolate bitters.
Pricing: No standalone spirits pricing; cocktail prices reflect spirit use.
How it sits with the food
The Rare Saint Manhattan's sweet vermouth and orange bitters could stand up to grilled steaks. A glass of Crocus Malbec from Cahors suits hearty dishes. The Espresso Martini Flight offers a sweet close to a meal.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.