Cocktail Bar
Unclaimed profileThe Storyville Lounge at Dr. Tumblety's
Pittsburgh, PA · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
The Storyville Lounge operates as a cocktail bar and distillery, pouring house-distilled spirits into historically themed drinks like the Storyville Sazerac and the Walter & Warrington Old Fashioned. Bar director Jaimee Mader's menu leans on local PA ingredients, with mocktails, Pennsylvania wines, and beers filling out the list.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Storyville Sazerac, made with house brandy, PA rye, and absinthe spray. The Walter & Warrington Old Fashioned showcases PA bourbon with Turner's tea demerara. For a lighter option, the Josie Arlington pairs botanical gin with mint and lemon. Housemade spirits like Apple Eaux De Vie are worth a straight pour.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Craft cocktail enthusiasts and local spirits fans will appreciate the house-distilled focus. The speakeasy theme and historically named drinks add curiosity. Those seeking a quick drink may find the handcrafted pace slow, but patient tasters will be rewarded. Non-drinkers are covered with two mocktails.
- When should I go?
- Evenings suit the speakeasy vibe, especially when live music or tastings are on. Weekday visits may have a quieter bar but limited cocktail options.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails range from $12 to $18; mocktails are $10, with a $6 spike option. Housemade spirits run $9 to $13 per 1.5 oz pour. Pennsylvania wines and beers are $10 and $4 respectively.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The venue is also a working distillery, producing eaux de vie, brandies, rums, gin, vodka, and moonshine on site. Chief distiller Mike Miles crafts small batches that anchor the cocktail program. The Storyville Lounge weaves this house production into a themed cocktail menu, creating a rare distillery-to-glass experience.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
Creative cocktails built on house-distilled spirits, curated by Jaimee Mader. Guests praise handcrafted, unique drinks, though service can be slow.
Menu strengths
- — House-distilled spirits in every cocktail; Historically themed recipes like the Storyville Sazerac
Standout selections
- — Storyville Sazerac – house brandy, PA rye, demerara, absinthe spray, $15
- — Walter & Warrington Old Fashioned – PA bourbon, Turner's tea demerara, bitters, $13
- — Josie Arlington – botanical gin, vermouth, mint, lemon, seltzer, $13
- — Summer Daiquiri – house white rum, rosé, strawberry, basil, lime, $13
Pricing: $12-$18
Wine
A minimal Pennsylvania wine list with three options: The Perfect Blanc, Red, and Rosé. Each is $10, offering local appeal but limited variety.
Standout selections
- — The Perfect Blanc – Pennsylvania wine, $10
- — The Perfect Red – Pennsylvania wine, $10
- — The Perfect Rosé – Pennsylvania wine, $10
Pricing: $10 per glass
Beer
Three Pennsylvania beers: Iron City, IC Light, and Turner's Ic'd Tea Beer, each $4. Local but basic selection.
Standout selections
- — Iron City – Pennsylvania beer, $4
- — IC Light – Pennsylvania beer, $4
- — Turner's Ic'd Tea Beer – Pennsylvania beer, $4
Pricing: $4 each
Nonalcoholic
Two mocktails: Minted Ginger Snap and Mediterranean Tonic, both $10. Option to add house gin or vodka for $6. Guests appreciate the non-alcoholic options.
Standout selections
- — Minted Ginger Snap – ginger, mint, lemon, soda, $10
- — Mediterranean Tonic – thyme, rosemary, black pepper, tonic & olive, $10
Pricing: $10 each
Spirits
Extensive house-distilled lineup: eaux de vie, brandies, rums, gin, vodka, moonshine. Small-batched and made on site. No whiskey offered, as noted in reviews.
Menu strengths
- — On-site distillery with copper stills; Diverse range of house-made spirits
Standout selections
- — Apple Eaux De Vie – housemade, $12
- — Peach Brandy – housemade, $13; Botanical Gin – housemade, $11
- — Old No.80 Apple Pie Moonshine – housemade, $9
Pricing: $9-$13 per pour; $40-$56 per bottle
How it sits with the food
No food menu is documented, but the house-made spirits and cocktails could pair with bar snacks or light fare. The local PA beer and wine options provide straightforward accompaniments. Guests might consider the Storyville Sazerac with savory bites, or the Summer Daiquiri with fresh fruit dishes.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.