
Brewery / taproom
Unclaimed profileOther Half Brewing Centre Street
Brooklyn, NY · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Other Half's original Centre Street taproom is still the most honest expression of the brewery: twenty rotating drafts in a spare room where production, not decor, supplies the identity. The brewery made its name on dense, aromatic hazy IPA, and hop saturation remains the gravitational center. The better news in 2026 is that the list no longer requires every drink to feel like a dare. Snaps, a 4.5% pilsner-style lager with Motueka and Saphir, brings lemon-lime lift, floral detail, and a clean finish. Forever Ever keeps Mosaic, Cashmere, and Citra intensity at 4.7%, proving that hop flavor need not arrive with double-IPA weight. Lime Snaps is a useful side experiment, though the added fruit makes it less diagnostic of the brewhouse than the plain lager. Start there, move through Forever Ever, then choose one full-strength IPA; that sequence distinguishes fermentation, hop expression, and alcohol instead of blurring three similar hazies together. Current independent criticism praises the beers as balanced and genuinely drinkable, while older drinker evidence identifies the persistent weakness: twenty handles do not always equal twenty distinct ideas. IPA and double IPA can crowd out malt-led, bitter, or mixed-fermentation styles. Draft freshness, direct access to new releases, and cans to go remain major strengths. There is little culinary infrastructure, so this is a tasting room rather than a complete night out. Centre Street earns an elite beer score because it offers world-class hop brewing with increasingly credible restraint, but broader style diversity would make the impressive tap count more meaningful.
- What should I order?
- Build a three-pour progression: Snaps first for clean fermentation and hop precision, Forever Ever second for session-strength haze, then one current full-strength IPA chosen by freshest keg rather than name recognition. Try Lime Snaps only after the unfruited lager.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Hop-focused drinkers, brewery pilgrims, and guests who want direct access to fresh releases will get the most from Centre Street. Traditionalists seeking cask ale, broad Belgian styles, or a food-led brewpub may find the twenty lines less varied than advertised.
- When should I go?
- Choose a weekday afternoon or early evening for room to compare pours and ask about keg dates. Weekend energy is livelier but lines and crowding make a careful tasting harder; check the live tap list immediately before traveling.
- What should I expect to spend?
- The current web tap list does not consistently expose draft prices. Confirm pour size and price at the bar, use smaller pours where offered, and reserve packaged-beer spending until after tasting the current batch on draft.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- This is the 2014 original: twenty draft lines beside the source of Other Half's reputation, with both fresh hazy IPA and increasingly convincing low-ABV counterpoints available in the same tasting sequence.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Beer
Exceptional freshness, influential hazy IPA, and newly persuasive lager and session-strength options make the original taproom essential. Repetition across hop-forward styles and limited food keep it below the very top tier.
Menu strengths
- — Twenty rotating drafts at the original brewery
- — Elite hop aroma and freshness with packaged releases to go
- — Credible lower-ABV range led by Snaps and Forever Ever
Standout selections
- — Snaps pilsner-style lager
- — Forever Ever session hazy IPA
- — Freshest current full-strength IPA
Pricing: Current draft prices are not consistently published online; confirm size and price at the bar and favor small pours for comparison.
How it sits with the food
Snacks are secondary and the venue is not a full brewpub. Salt and fat suit the hop beers, but eat a proper meal nearby; palate fatigue arrives quickly when strong, aromatic IPA is treated as dinner.
Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.