nebrious
Photo of The Hamilton Supperette & Lounge

Restaurant

Unclaimed profile

The Hamilton Supperette & Lounge

Oklahoma City, OK

Inebrious Beverage Program Score: 85 out of 100

Inebrious

Beverage Program Score

Research completed 2026-09-01 · Based on current public sources

Editor: Micah Rousey

Review methodology and evidence standards

The editorial take

The Hamilton Supperette & Lounge pairs a supperette's casual comfort with a cocktail list that leans into dessert classics and a few modern twists. The zero-proof program is unusually thorough, and the post-dinner spirits list reaches into premium cognac and amaro. Wine and beer stay simple and affordable. A place for sweet-toothed drinkers and those who want a proper non-alcoholic option.

What should I order?
Start with the Old School Fashioned, a bargain at $8. For dessert, the Chocolate Old Fashioned swaps in Ron Zacapa 23 rum, and the Hamilton Espresso Martini is a reliable pick. The Phony Negroni offers a convincing zero-proof alternative. After dinner, consider a pour of Baardsath XO Cognac or a dram of Fernet Branca.
Who will enjoy this place?
Drinkers who appreciate a well-rounded cocktail program with a sweet tooth, plus those seeking thoughtful zero-proof options. The limited wine and beer lists may not satisfy enthusiasts, but the cocktail and spirits selection offers enough depth for a casual night out.
When should I go?
Evenings when you want a dessert cocktail or a post-dinner digestif. The dessert cocktail menu and spirits list suggest a late-night or after-dinner occasion.
What should I expect to spend?
Cocktails range from $8 for the Old School Fashioned to $14 for the Hamilton Espresso Martini. Wine is uniformly $7 per glass. Premium spirits are priced per ounce, with JCB at $50/0.5oz, $100/1oz, and $200/2oz, and Quintessence at $65/1oz.
What makes the beverage program distinctive?
A dedicated dessert cocktail menu and a zero-proof program that includes four non-alcoholic cocktails, plus a post-dinner spirits list with rare cognacs and amari. The inclusion of a $200 pour of JCB signals a willingness to go premium, while the $7 wine and domestic beer keep the bar approachable.

Beverage categories

We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.

Cocktails

Inebrious Cocktails score: 88 out of 100

The cocktail menu spans dessert classics, modern twists, and a few originals. The dessert section is a highlight, with six options including the Elijah Lebowski and Chocolate Old Fashioned.

Menu strengths

  • — Diverse dessert cocktail menu with creative combinations like Elijah Craig, Copa de Oro, and half & half.
  • — Community praise for specialty cocktails, including a spicy cowboy drink and a pain killer.

Standout selections

  • — Elijah Lebowski: Elijah Craig, Copa de Oro, half & half
  • — Chocolate Old Fashioned: Ron Zacapa 23yr rum, chocolate bitters
  • — Hamilton Espresso Martini: Nespresso, Stoli vanilla, Bailey's

Pricing: Old School Fashioned $8; Hamilton Espresso Martini $14

Nonalcoholic

Inebrious Nonalcoholic score: 87 out of 100

The zero-proof program is a standout, with four crafted non-alcoholic cocktails: Tropical Creamsicle, Nespresso Mocktini, Phony Negroni, and Hot Girl Summer. Also offers non-alcoholic beers. A thoughtful alternative for designated drivers or abstainers.

Menu strengths

  • — Four distinct zero-proof cocktails with creative flavor combinations.
  • — Includes non-alcoholic beer options, expanding choices for non-drinkers.

Standout selections

  • — Phony Negroni: St. Agrestis, orange peel
  • — Hot Girl Summer: jalapeño, sweet & sour, Topo Chico, choice of watermelon, blackberry, or strawberry

Pricing: No specific prices listed for zero-proof cocktails

Spirits

Inebrious Spirits score: 84 out of 100

The Post Dinner Dram list features premium cognacs and amari, including JCB, Quintessence, D'usse XO, Baardsath XO, and Fernet Branca. Priced by the ounce, these are intended for sipping after a meal.

Menu strengths

  • — Premium selection of cognacs and amari, including rare pours like JCB.
  • — Priced per ounce, allowing guests to sample high-end spirits without committing to a full bottle.

Standout selections

  • — JCB: $50/0.5oz, $100/1oz, $200/2oz; Quintessence: $65/1oz

Pricing: JCB $50/0.5oz, $100/1oz, $200/2oz; Quintessence $65/1oz; D'usse XO $50; Baardsath XO Cognac $22

How it sits with the food

The dessert cocktails, such as the Brandy Alexander and Grasshopper, are designed to follow a meal. The post-dinner spirits list, including cognacs and amari, serves as a digestif course. For earlier in the meal, the Perfect Margarita or Paloma could complement lighter fare, though the menu's focus on sweets suggests pairing with dessert.

Inebrious does not score kitchens, food or the restaurant overall. We review the beverage program only.

About this review

Research is based on recent public evidence, including official venue materials and beverage menus when available. The review date is the research completion date and does not imply an in-person visit.

Review methodology and evidence standards

Community reviews

Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.

No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.

Also worth a drink