Bar
Unclaimed profileThieves Guild Cidery
Salt Lake City, UT · $$
Inebrious
Beverage Program Score
The editorial take
Thieves Guild Cidery leans into fantasy with themed cocktails like Princess Peach's Tea Party and the potion-style Health Potion and Mana Potion. The cocktail list is creative, with house-made sodas and syrups. Beer, nonalcoholic drinks, and spirits round out a broad menu. Guests mention the potion bottles and elf-ear-wearing bartenders as part of the experience.
- What should I order?
- Start with the Health Potion, a rye whiskey, Fernet, tart cherry, and lemon mix that one guest called a favorite. For something lighter, the Princess Peach's Tea Party uses Beehive Jackrabbit Gin and house-made white tea peach ginger beer.
- Who will enjoy this place?
- Fans of themed bars and fantasy settings will appreciate the creative cocktails and atmosphere. The nonalcoholic options, including house-made sodas and an NA IPA, also make it welcoming for designated drivers.
- What should I expect to spend?
- Cocktails run $12 to $15, with many in the $12 range. Beer ranges from $3 to $9, and nonalcoholic drinks are $3 to $5. Spirit pours are $3 to $13 depending on the pour.
- What makes the beverage program distinctive?
- The cocktail menu is built around fantasy references, with drinks like the Solaire Sazerac and L.S.P. The potion-style drinks come in unique bottles, and guests mention bartenders wearing elf ears, reinforcing the tavern theme.
Beverage categories
We only score what a venue sets out to do. Categories a venue doesn't attempt are left unscored rather than penalized.
Cocktails
A themed cocktail list with original creations like L.S.P. And Shillelagh. Guests specifically praise the Health Potion and Mana Potion, served in distinctive bottles.
Menu strengths
- — Creative fantasy-themed cocktails with names like Solaire Sazerac and Princess Peach's Tea Party.
- — Several cocktails incorporate house-made sodas, syrups, and other crafted components.
Standout selections
- — Health Potion — Rye Whiskey, Fernet, Tart Cherry, Lemon; praised by guests as a favorite.
- — Mana Potion — Rum, Mint, Lime, and Blue Curacao; also highlighted by guests.
- — Princess Peach's Tea Party — Beehive Jackrabbit Gin with house-made white tea peach ginger beer.
Pricing: $12-$15
Beer
A straightforward beer list mixing domestic and craft options. Guinness is on tap, and the selection includes Fisher Beer, Fisher Cerveza, Templin Family Ferda IPA, and Coors Banquet. Priced affordably, with Coors Banquet at $3.
Menu strengths
- — Range of options from a $3 Coors Banquet to a $9 Templin Family Ferda IPA.
- — Includes both familiar domestic and craft beer choices.
Standout selections
- — Guinness on tap — $7; Templin Family Ferda IPA — $9
Pricing: $3-$9
Nonalcoholic
Thoughtful nonalcoholic options beyond standard sodas. Includes Athletic Run Wild IPA on draft and house-made sodas like Strawberry Thai basil shrub soda and Peach White Tea Ginger Beer. Standard sodas are also available for $3.
Menu strengths
- — House-made sodas such as Strawberry Thai basil shrub soda and Pomegranate Lime Soda.
- — Athletic Run Wild IPA provides a nonalcoholic craft beer option on draft.
Standout selections
- — Athletic Run Wild IPA — $5, on draft
Pricing: $3-$5
Spirits
A wide-ranging spirits list organized by category, from vodka and gin to scotch and amaro. Pours are priced per glass, with two pour sizes offered. Includes local Beehive Jackrabbit gin and a barrel-aged honey spirit featured in a cocktail.
Menu strengths
- — Broad selection across eight spirit categories.; Offers two pour sizes, allowing customers to choose their serving.
Standout selections
- — Ardbeg 10 Year — $10/$13; Blade & Bow bourbon — $8/$10
Pricing: $3-$13 per pour
Community reviews
Anyone with a free Inebrious account can rate the drinks here. Community ratings are kept entirely separate from the Inebrious editorial score above.
No community reviews yet. Be the first to write one.